Skip to main content
Engineering Insights

Do You Need A Structural Engineer Or A Civil Engineer?

George KhalilFounder & Principal Engineer5 min read

You need a structural engineer for the parts of a building that carry load: the footings, slabs, columns, beams, walls and roof framing. You need a civil engineer for the works around and under the building that deal with the ground surface and the water, such as stormwater, site levels, driveways and earthworks. A multi-storey development needs both, working from the same set of levels.

People mix the two up for a fair reason. Structural engineering grew out of civil engineering, and my own degree is a Bachelor of Engineering in Civil. On a building project, though, the two words describe different scopes of work, and they produce separate sets of drawings.

What a structural engineer designs

A structural engineer designs everything that holds the building up and keeps it standing against wind and earthquake. That means the footings and piles, the ground slabs and suspended slabs, the columns, walls and beams, and the steel and timber framing. On a building with a basement, it also covers the retaining walls, the shoring and the bulk excavation.

Structural drawings say how big each member is, what reinforcement goes in it and how it connects to the next one. Assessment reports, remediation of existing structures and inspections before each concrete pour sit on the structural side too. The fuller picture is in [what structural engineering is](/blog/what-is-structural-engineering-complete-guide).

What a civil engineer designs

A civil engineer designs how the site handles water and levels. That covers the stormwater pits and pipes, on-site detention, the finished levels across the site, driveways and pavements, earthworks, and the erosion and sediment control plan for construction.

On our projects, civil scope also covers Sydney Water Section 73 compliance, Specialist Engineering Assessments and engineering assessment reports for Transport for NSW. How that plays out on a larger building is described in [the role of civil engineering in multi-storey developments](/blog/role-of-civil-engineering-multi-storey-developments).

The overlap

Plenty of items sit across the line. A retaining wall is structure, while the water behind it is civil. A basement ramp is a structural slab whose levels come from the civil design and the street, and a basement's drainage has to suit both the structure and the stormwater system.

On a basement project the overlap sits at almost every edge. The structural engineer sizes the basement walls for the soil and water pressure behind them, while the civil engineer decides where that water goes, how the driveway meets the street and what the lowest floor drains to.

These overlaps are where projects lose time. When the structural and civil designs come from separate offices, each set can be right on its own and still disagree about a level.

When it is a geotechnical question

If the question is about the ground itself, meaning what it is made of and what it will carry, you need a geotechnical engineer. The geotechnical investigation classifies the soil and rock and sets the design values, and the structural engineer then designs the footings and shoring from them. Reading that report is covered in [understanding geotechnical investigation reports](/blog/understanding-geotechnical-investigation-reports).

Alterations to existing buildings

For an alteration to an existing commercial or apartment building, such as a new opening in a wall or new plant on a roof, the work is usually structural on its own. Civil design comes in once there is new hard surface draining somewhere, a new driveway, or a council condition about stormwater.

Registration in NSW

In NSW, engineers who prepare regulated designs for apartment buildings register as design practitioners, and structural and civil engineering are registered as separate classes. I hold both. The scheme is explained in [design practitioner registration in NSW](/blog/design-practitioner-registration-nsw).

How we approach it

At ACSES the structural, civil and geotechnical engineers work as one team. One set of levels feeds the footings, the stormwater and the driveway, so a change in one shows up in all three before anything reaches site.

When one team draws the building and the ground around it, a level only has to be right once.

ACSES provides structural, civil and geotechnical engineering under one team across Sydney. Talk to us about a project.

Building Relationships Beyond Structures

George Khalil

George Khalil

Founder & Principal Engineer

almost three decades of structural, civil, and geotechnical engineering experience across 1,000+ projects.

Structural EngineeringCivil EngineeringGeotechnicalScopeConsultants

Tell us about your project.

We will respond with a clear understanding of how we can assist.

Partner With Us